
Brands Turn to Handmade Ads as AI Skepticism Grows
Studios that build ads by hand are winning business while AI pushes the rest of the industry to cut prices and jobs. Stop-motion, claymation and hand-drawn animation studios report rising demand. Apartment D Films, the Burbank, Calif., studio that animated e.l.f. Beauty’s holiday spot, estimates its inbound inquiries have doubled in two years.
Oregon-based Stunt Puppet Pictures says it has been fully booked for the past year and now turns down commercial work. London studio Blinkink says commercials are carrying its business while financing for long-form projects slows.
E.l.f. Chief Marketing Officer Oshiya Savur told the Journal the campaign was not a response to AI. She said the brand wanted a distinct look at a time when AI imagery is everywhere.
Public sentiment is moving the same way. In a Gallup and Bentley University poll, 39% of Americans said technology does more harm than good in 2026, up from 31% in 2025.
Brands are also publishing behind-the-scenes footage to show the work is handmade. Apple’s making-of clip for its claymation Mac Mini ad has more than 197 million Instagram views. Greg Hahn, co-founder of the agency Mischief, said consumers value visible effort, especially frame-by-frame work.
Recent campaigns show the trend. E.l.f.’s holiday ad features puppets wearing real makeup. Levi’s ran a stop-motion spot based on its 1995 “Clayman” commercial. Prada combined live action with hand-drawn illustration. Apple used glasswork, embroidery, stop-motion and practical effects across several 2026 projects. In 2024, Apple apologized for an ad that showed a machine crushing creative tools.
Some in the creative community call the practice “effort signaling.” Animators also worry that AI can fake process videos. One viral Instagram Reel, presented as a miniature city being filmed in a wave tank, drew nearly 900 million views. It was made entirely with AI.
Full story: WSJ
Last Call: UK Summit in London
A new generation of clients believes in people and culture over institutions, and they can spot a manufactured narrative in seconds. Inside your own firm, the communicators who understand this are earning a seat at the table, not just advising those who sit there.
None of this gets solved on a slide. That's the whole premise behind this year's theme: The Return of the Room. One day. One room. The most senior marketing and communications leaders in financial services, face-to-face.
🗓 Date: Tuesday 24th November
⏰ Time: 8am – 2pm GMT
📍 Location: Charlotte Street Hotel, London
The Financial Narrative UK Summit brings senior marketing and comms leaders together from across financial services, banks, insurers, fintechs, and asset managers for a day of conversation you can't get anywhere else. Spaces are limited. Review the agenda and reserve your seat here >>>

